Mini Book Reviews: The Club Dumas and The Moon is a Harsh Mistress

Since I’m super behind on my book reviews, I’m going to try writing some “mini” book reviews. I’m hopeful that writing a mini review will take some of the pressure off of writing full-fledged reviews so that I might be inspired to write a few more. 🙂


Mini Book Reviews:



Club Dumas

Synopsis adapted from Goodreads:

Lucas Corso, middle-aged, tired, and cynical, is a book detective, a mercenary hired to hunt down rare editions for wealthy and unscrupulous clients. When a well-known bibliophile is found hanged, leaving behind part of the original manuscript of Alexandre Dumas’s “The Three Musketeers, ” Corso is brought in to authenticate the fragment.The task seems straightforward, but the unsuspecting Corso is soon drawn into a swirling plot involving devil worship, occult practices, and swashbuckling derring-do among a cast of characters bearing a suspicious resemblance to those of Dumas’s masterpiece. Aided by a mysterious beauty named for a Conan Doyle heroine, Corso travels from Madrid to Toledo to Paris in pursuit of a sinister and seemingly omniscient killer.

I was really excited to read this book based on the description alone. A rare book collector trying to authenticate a previously unknown chapter of The Three Musketeers–sign me up! Initially the novel really seemed to live up to all the hype. It was mysterious, fast-paced, and I loved learning more about Dumas and book binding. Then, the novel picked up a second plot line (i.e. the search for The Nine Doors) and things started to get sort of muddled for me. It probably didn’t help that I was listening to an audiobook instead of reading a print version, but it just seemed like these two story-lines did not mesh well together at all.  I think this book would have been so much stronger if Perez-Reverte had either stuck with one plot line or had done a better job of fleshing both out.  I definitely don’t regret reading this book, but I wouldn’t want to read it again. 2.5/5 stars (rounded up to 3 on Goodreads).



Synopsis adapted from Goodreads:

It is the year 2076, and the Moon is a penal colony for the rebellious and the unwanted of Earth. The exiles have created a libertarian society in order to survive in their harsh and unforgiving environment, their motto being TANSTAAFL: “There ain’t no such thing as a free lunch”. Looming over them is the Luna Authority, the heavy-handed Earth administration, who trades life necessities to the “Loonies” in exchange for grain shipments to the starving populations of Earth.

As the situation steadily deteriorates the inhabitants of Luna come to realize that they have little choice but to revolt against Luna Authority in order to save themselves from resource exhaustion and a subsequent environmental apocalypse.

A small band of dissidents emerges to lead the revolution. This consists of a one-armed computer jock, a radical young woman, a past-his-prime academic, and a nearly omnipotent computer named Mike. These people ignite the fires of revolution, despite the near certainty of failure.

Of the 55 books I’ve read so far this year, only 2 of them can be considered “science fiction.” Clearly sci-fi is not a genre I read very often. So last year when a labmate suggested I read this book, I filed it away in my head for a “maybe someday when I’m really bored” book. Well that day came earlier this year when I really wanted to check out an audiobook from the library and everything else I was interested in was already checked out (I hate it when that happens!). I remembered this book and saw that it was available so I checked it out, and I’m really glad I did.

The story opens with Manuel (i.e. Mannie), who is a resident of the lunar colonies (i.e. “Loonies”). He is a computer technician for the master computers of the Lunar Authority, which is the lunar government established and run by the people of the Earth. One day Mannie discovers that one of the computers has “awakened” (i.e developed a self-awareness), and he develops a sort of friendship with the computer whom he calls “Mike.” In the midst of this burgeoning friendship a revolution is brewing amongst the lunar colonists, and Mannie and Mike quickly get swept up in the fight for independence.

Initially, the story was sort of hard to get into and I didn’t feel like I really understood what was going on. I eventually realized this was because the people of the lunar colony have different vocabulary and a strange way of phrasing sentences, but once I got used it I began to really enjoy the story. The Loonies and the place they live in are very different from my own, but Heinlein does such a fantastic job of world-building that I could imagine what it was like to live there. I was also impressed that the technology described didn’t seem too dated even though this book was published almost 50 years ago!

Despite the futuristic setting, this a book about politics at its core. While I may not have agreed with all of Heinlein’s theories, I found myself really thinking about the nature of revolutions and what it takes to build a nation from scratch. Mannie and his friends enter into the revolution with high ideals, but they quickly discover these theories don’t always hold up well in the real world. Heinlein’s descriptions of the intrigues and infighting of the new lunar politicians is eerily similar to that of the present day U. S. Congress.

Overall, I thought this was a really good read. It’s chock-full of political theory, but also has enough action to keep the story moving. I also thought the reader of the audiobook, Lloyd James, did an awesome job with the various accents and dialects of the characters. 4/5 stars.



2 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. Trackback: November and December 2014 Recap | Ex Libris
  2. Trackback: My 2014 Reading Challenges: How did I do? | Ex Libris

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: